Awards yes, awards no: in praise of our contradiction
BlogReflections

Awards yes, awards no: in praise of our contradiction

Awards give us visibility and boost our self-esteem, but they also make us suspicious and angry. An honest reflection, with a bit of dialectics, on why we change our minds every season.

13 November 20265 min readMarkel Orozko
Scroll to read

At Belve, few topics have given us as many headaches as awards. Every time a call for entries opens, the same scene plays out: someone shares it in the group chat, someone else asks “shall we enter?”, and a conversation starts that never ends the same way twice.

The funny thing is that we almost never argue for lack of arguments, but because we have too many. Far too many, and they point in opposite directions.

An endless list of “on the other hand”

If we had to sum up our relationship with awards, it would go something like this:

  • We don’t like showing off, or putting ourselves down. On the other hand, we know an award brings visibility, and visibility brings projects.
  • We know plenty of cases where there’s rigging or favouritism. On the other hand, having someone from outside tell us we’re doing well boosts our self-esteem more than we’d like to admit.
  • It annoys us to pay organisations when we don’t really know how they’re set up or who’s behind them. On the other hand, we’re a bit stingy and always end up entering local awards that don’t cost a thing.
  • There are seasons when we feel like entering everything. On the other hand, there are others when we want nothing to do with any of it.

For a long time we experienced it as an inconsistency, almost a flaw that needed fixing. Until we realised that maybe the problem wasn’t the contradiction, but the way we were looking at it.

Contradiction isn’t a mistake, it’s the engine

Some 2,500 years ago, Heraclitus already sensed that everything is in motion and that things are defined by the tension between opposites. Many centuries later, Hegel turned that intuition into a method: reality moves forward precisely because it is shot through with contradictions that push it to transform. (Incidentally, he hardly ever used the famous “thesis, antithesis, synthesis” formula; we owe it mostly to those who interpreted him later.)

Marx and Engels turned Hegel on his head and brought the idea down to earth. Dialectical materialism starts from the premise that contradictions don’t exist only in ideas, but in the material conditions we live in. And that they aren’t resolved by denying one of the poles, but by understanding the relationship between them.

Seen this way, our “yes, but no” with awards stops being a character flaw. It’s a real contradiction, with two forces genuinely pulling: the need to be seen and the need to stay honest.

What we think depends on how we live

Marx put it in writing in 1859: it is not consciousness that determines social being, but social being that determines consciousness. Applied to a small agency in Bilbao, that sentence explains our seasons pretty well.

When there’s plenty of work, projects fill us up and outside validation matters little: the best award is a happy client. When things slow down, the doubts creep in, along with the urge for someone to tell us we’re on the right track and the temptation to enter everything. We don’t change our minds on a whim; our circumstances change, and with them, what we need.

Something similar happens with money. Many competitions are funded by entry fees: the more projects entered, the more income. That isn’t necessarily bad, but it’s worth knowing. Being annoyed at paying isn’t just stinginess; it’s the reasonable suspicion that we’re funding a shop window rather than recognising a piece of work.

The symbolic value of a medal

The sociologist Pierre Bourdieu spoke of symbolic capital: the prestige and recognition that, without being money, end up turning into opportunities. An award is exactly that. A sign of consecration anyone can read at a glance: “if they’ve been given this, they must be doing something right.”

The problem is that the value of that consecration depends on who does the consecrating. If we don’t know how the jury is chosen, who funds the organisation or what interests lie behind it, that capital becomes fragile. And an agency that flies the flag of honesty can’t afford to hang medals of dubious origin around its neck.

The principal contradiction and the secondary ones

In On Contradiction (1937), Mao Zedong puts forward a very practical idea: many contradictions coexist in any process, but there is always a principal one that conditions the rest. Identifying it helps you not to get lost along the way.

In our case, the principal contradiction is clear: visibility versus honesty. Everything else —the cost, the ego, the fear of rigging, the urge to celebrate— revolves around that tension. When we keep it in mind, deciding becomes much simpler.

Our (provisional) synthesis

We haven’t found a definitive answer, and there probably isn’t one. But we have found a few criteria that help us move within the contradiction without being paralysed by it:

  • We enter awards where we know who’s behind them, how the jury is chosen and what is being judged.
  • We prioritise local awards and those that don’t charge to take part, or that charge in a reasonable and transparent way.
  • We submit work we’re proud of, and that the client is proud of too.
  • When recognition comes, we celebrate it and share it, but without making it the centre of what we say.
  • And we never let a medal replace our own judgement.

This year, for example, we received two Brandor medals: one for best naming and another for best design of a new visual identity. We were thrilled and shared it proudly. But we know that what matters isn’t the medal, but the project and the people who trusted us to do it.

In praise of inconsistency

I suppose this is one of the many inconsistencies we humans have, and one that Belve, as a company made of people, carries too. But we’ve learned not to be ashamed of it. An agency that never doubts anything probably never asks itself whether it’s getting things right either.

So we’ll keep having seasons of entering and seasons of refusing. We’ll keep arguing in the group chat every time a call for entries opens. And if one day you see us go up to collect an award, know that we’ll do it with one hand on our heart and the other scratching our head.

The end
Markel Orozko

Written by

Markel Orozko

Co-founder & director en Belvedere, agencia de marketing y comunicación en Bilbao. Meet the team →

Next articleBrand archetypes: Jung’s 12 archetypes applied to branding